Four oil brands running four completely different content playbooks, what each one wins, and how to pick the one that fits your brand.

Let's get into it →

Motor oil is one of the most commoditized products in automotive. Your customer can't see it working. Most can't tell one brand from another in a blind test.

But that doesn't stop them from having some of the most prolific brands in the industry.

If they can build a brand for motor oil, you can surely build one for your widget.

In a commodity category, your creative is your positioning. Let’s look at four brands.

Mobil 1 runs the embedded playbook. They live inside motorsports and esports, capturing content from real moments as they happen. The advantage: a compounding war chest of branded content with built-in authenticity. You can't fake being in the room, and their library grows every race weekend.

Pennzoil runs the franchise playbook. Car culture as entertainment, built around big-production series. The famous Joyride Campaign made them the brand for enthusiasts. They garnered 35 industry awards, web traffic doubled, engagement 10X'ed, search traffic 8X'ed. The advantage: a repeatable format compounds where one-off spots evaporate. Every episode compounds the brand association.

Valvoline runs the efficiency playbook. Tight, conversion-focused campaigns, heavy on paid media, meeting customers exactly where they are. The advantage: predictable, measurable revenue at the lowest content cost in the category. When margin math is tight, this playbook keeps the lights on and the CFO calm.

Castrol runs the regional playbook. Content varies by market, which reads as scattered from a global view but buys them something the others don't have: local resonance. A campaign built for one region can hit harder in that region than any global asset ever will.

Four systems. Four different bets. All four printing money.

1. They think there's one correct playbook.

Operators see a competitor's content winning and assume that's the way to do it. But Pennzoil's (owned by Shell) franchise strategy would outspend Valvoline's budget, and Valvoline's efficiency play would waste Mobil 1's motorsports access. The playbook isn't right or wrong. It's matched or mismatched.

2. They copy the output instead of the position.

Copycatting the creative from these brands alone is a mistake. The Creative only works because it supports the positioning. Find the right positioning for your brand and build creative backwards from that goal.

3. They run all playbooks at once, which is running none.

Creative doesn't build a brand overnight. It builds it over the thousands of touch points your customers have with your brand over years. Trying to do a little bit of everything ends up diluting your message.

Pick the playbook your advantages can feed. Then run it long enough to compound.